|Big discounts on
stuff you want!
is hands down the best site on the Web for classic TV.'
shows on DVD
Though the hosts, the set and the worst-dressed change from year to year, often TV’s annual Emmy presentation (like the one that aired last Sunday night) comes across like just another rerun.
That’s because, often, the same people win in the same categories year after year. Both Allison Janney (of “Mom”) and Tony Hale (of “Veep”) claimed repeat wins the other night.
And before “Veep” wrestled the award away from it, “Modern Family” had claimed five “Outstanding Sitcom” statues in a row. And before Jeffrey Tambor came on strong with his role in “Transparent,” Jim Parsons (who may have recused himself this year) took home four in a row for his role on “Big Bang Theory.” Meanwhile, Julia Louis-Dreyfus just nabbed her fourth in a row for “Veep.” Back in the day, Candice Bergen grabbed five for her work on “Murphy Brown”; Tyne Daly in “Cagney & Lacey” seemed to have a lock on the Best Actress category for a time, taking the award home four times; and, in the 1980s, “Hill Street Blues” took home the award for Best Drama five years in row. (“Hill Street’s” record has since been matched by “L.A. Law,” “The West Wing,” and “Mad Men.”)
With this high number of repeat winners every year, it’s not surprising that often, the morning after the telecast, viewers are often left with a feeling of “What was the point?”
Of course, awards and any sort of “Best” superlatives ever handed out for any sort of creative effort is, inherently, suspect and fraught with debate and even controversy. Ultimately, there’s no scientific way to determine if one performance is better than another. A variety of factors always figure in as to why one person takes home the gold and the other doesn’t. (The again, I also think, in regard to the Oscars, Emmys, et.al., that we spend way too much time Monday Morning Quarterbacking everything—finding or creating reasons why someone will win or not win and too seldom thinking, Hey, maybe they won because, you know, they gave a good performance?)
Still, the annual Emmys are in a unique and sometimes difficult position. Baring the occasional successful sequel, the Oscars never have to reward the same person for the same role more than once. Ditto the Tonys and the Grammys where, there too, the yearly presentations have a strict (and logical) “one-and-done” policy no matter how successful a movie is or how long a stage show runs.
In contrast, a hit TV series can run for years and years, with the same cast, often playing (and perhaps playing quite well) the same role and thus enabling the same performers to win in the same categories year after year.
So what do we do with this “problem”? And, moreover, is it a “problem” at all?
Considering the aforementioned subjective nature of these awards, perhaps it would behoove the Emmys to adopt some sort of “one-per-customer” rule. Perhaps a “gentlemen’s agreement” could be put in place that says after one win (or two or maybe three, tops) you are no longer in the running ever again, if only to make room for some new blood.
Actually, often times it falls to the performer themselves to decide when they’ve been honored enough and then choose to not submit their name/work for Emmy consideration; note the absence of Jim Parsons from the noms this year. This recusing is what John Larroquette eventually did after four consecutive years of Emmy love for his role on “Night Court” and what Candice Bergen ultimately did after her fifth win for “Murphy Brown.”
Other times, sheer fatigue and lack of newness eventually removes performers from active consideration. A case in point: the first season of “The Golden Girls” in 1984, not surprisingly, all three of its leading ladies—Betty White, Bea Arthur and Rue McClanahan—were nominated for Outstanding Actress in a Comedy Series. White won that year first year. All three were nominated again the following year with McClanahan winning that time. The year after that, all three were nominated again with Arthur taking home the award. All three “Golden Girls” would be nominated the year after that but lost to Candice Bergen who was just beginning her streak as “Murphy Brown.” That year (1988-89) also marked the final time all three “Golden Girls” would be nominated. But “The Golden Girls” stayed on the air until 1992. So what happened? Did White, McClanahan and Arthur suddenly become less talented or have less expertise in their roles?
No, but some new faces came to the tube and to that category including Kirstie Alley, Helen Hunt and Roseanne. And, so, voters apparently thought it was time to share the wealth and make room for the next generation. The “Girls,” it seems, had had their day(s) in the sun and it was now time for them to move on and let the newbies take over.
Despite the phenomenon of repeat winners, it can be argued, that if a performer is doing good work, season after season, regardless of how many times they’ve won in the past, they still deserve to be recognized again even if it makes the awards seem as if they are in a rut. After all, the best is still the best, even if we’ve seen it before.
Due to the repeat nature and long-term eligibility unique to the Emmys, in many ways, the TV industry awards are less like the Oscars than they are, say, like the World Series, the Super Bowl or tennis’s US Open where the same teams and/or players have the chance to take the top prize year after year. Though she defaulted this year, Serena Williams grabbed her sixth US Open title last year. On the men’s side, in the early and mid-2000s, Roger Federer won five US Open titles in a row. Yet, despite their plethora of repeat victories, no one has yet demanded that Williams and/or Federer recuse themselves from this annual tournament, or any other one for that matter. In fact, asking them or any athlete or talented sports team to not play and compete to the best of their abilities is actually rather insulting, flying in the face of what athletics and competition is supposed to be all about.
But, of course, the Emmys are about art, not athletics. And art is not made to be measured via such qualifiers as speed or distance or serves returned. Furthermore, hopefully, no performer is performing with the idea of getting awards in mind but for the joy of performing and in bringing something to their audience. Which then, of course, calls into question not only the issue of “winners” and repeat winners but the idea of awards in general.
Post-Modern Sitcoms / Actors That Wrote Books / 1987 Gilbert Gottfried Pilot Written By Larry David / Tarantino, DiCaprio & Pitt on Once Upon A Time In Hollywood / Ray Liotta and Joe Pesci Talk Goodfellas / Coming to America - The Awful Sitcom? / Robert Wagner Interview / Helen Mirren on 1923 / Lucky 19-Year Old Birthday Boy on The Price is Right / 1990-1999 TV Commercials / James Hong on the First & Only Asian Talent Agent in Hollywood / More Than Myagi: The Pat Morita Story / Chevy Chase 2021 Interview / Ally McBeal and that Darn Dancing Baby / Ed Begley Jr. Interview / Peter Boyle's Heart Attack on the Set of Everybody Loves Raymond / Patrick Swayze Refused To Do 'Ghost' Without Whoopie Goldberg / Clark Furlong on Stephen King's Mini-Series Lisey's Story / 14-Year Old Brody Bett Steals the Show at a David Foster Concert / Worst Big Budget Superhero Movie of All Time / Jerry Springer's Toxic TV Legacy / Three Generations of Talent / One Season Too Many / Dick Wolf on the Writer's Strike / Angela Lansbury Tribute / Houston Knights / Uncle Buck Sitcom / My Brush With King Charles / Bonnie Bartlett Daniels Interview / Frank Zappa Talk Show? / Remembering Marvel & Buffy Scribe Pierce Askegren / Piper Laurie Tribute / 1993 Route 66 Reboot / David Hyde Pierce on the Last Days of ‘Frazier’ / Angela Lansbury Interview / The Shadow Movies of the 1930s & 40s / Remembering Hal Holbrook / Remembering Angela Lansbury / Greensboro Movie Theaters : Star Theatre / Police Squad Shot-By-Shot Remake of M Squad! / A Painting Saved Bill Murray's Life / Why Jim Carrey Fought to Cast Jeff Daniels in 'Dumb and Dumber' / Meredith Baxter Talks Breast Cancer / Sopranos Creator David Chase Had to Fight to Make Tony Soprano the Mobster He Was / Joan Collins on Working With Drunk Actors / Snowmaggedon 1969 / Joe Pesci HATES Practical Jokes / Books About Showbiz / Making It in Showbiz / Dark Justice / My Fave Book About Showbiz / Remembering Billy Packer / More Celebrity Biographies / Peter Falk : Inside The Actor's Studio / Jason Alexander on Duckman / Robert Ebert on Robert Mitchum / Watch Dave Chappelle's New Netflix Special for Free / Margaret (Wicked Witch of the West) Hamilton Was Almost Scarred For Life Filming Wizard of Oz / Restaurant Chains We Might Lose In 2020 / Night Heat / Short History of TV Advertising / Is Ellen A Monster? / To Binge Or Not To Binge? / 1986-87 TV SEASON / Celebrity Bios 4 / 1988-89 TV SEASON / 1990-91 TV SEASON / Can Comic Book City Survive? / When TV Plays Politics for Laughs / The Worst Thing I Ever Saw (Part 2) / Greensboro's Beef (Biff) Burger Has Closed! / Sally Field Looks Back on Smokey and the Bandit / Actors Writing Memoirs 2 / Gene Wilder's Sexual Chemistry with Richard Pryor / WORST Pizzas Served On Kitchen Nightmares / Ricky Gervais' Cruelly Funny 2020 Golden Globe Monologue / What It's Like To Win A New Car on The Price Is Right / Night Train! 3 - Las Vegas Comic Pat Cooper / Night Train! 4 - Resurrection and Death of Louis Prima / Denis Shepard of Paradise Lost / Space Force Logo is a Ripoff from Star Trek! / Batman Movie from 1939? What?!? / Michael Richards (Kramer) Really Hated It When his Seinfeld Co-Stars Messed Up / Melissa McCarthy Almost Quit Acting Days Before Landing Gilmore Girls / Bar Rescue's Wildest Customers! / How The Golden Girls and Elvis Got Tarantino's Reservoir Dogs Made / Charlie Brown Voice Actor Released From Prison / New Year's Eve on TV / Sir Laurence Olivier on the 'Genius' of Marlon Brando / 1967 Futurists Predict The 21st Century / Remembering Diahann Carroll / 50 Funniest Niles Crane Insults / TV HITS - By the Numbers / How Tom Hanks Played Mr. Rogers / Colin Farrell as The Penguin? / Alex Baldwin On His TV and Film Roles / Ray Charles' BIG Problem With TV / Malcolm Gladwell on TV Crime Dramas / Why Dolly Parton Would Not Let Elvis Record 'I Will Always Love You' / Top Ten Sitcoms of the 1970s / Danny McBride Rebooting Hogan's Heroes? / Fashion on TV / Alive & Well / James Cameron Made No Money for Titanic / Whatever Happened To Miss Cleo? / Lucy Blows Off Burt Reynolds / Dave Navarro Meets His Mother's Killer / The Real Mindhunters Killers / John Goodman Breaks Down His Iconic Roles / Growing Up In The Playboy Mansion / Ed McMahon Drunk on the Air! / Lucy Interviewed by Barbara Walters / Valerie Harper Cancer / Jeff Bridges Breaks Down His Iconic Roles / Dog Fight! The KCNC Scandal / Buckley vs Hefner / Laurence Olivier vs Marilyn Monroe / Dallas vs Eight is Enough / 1974 MAD Magazine TV Special - Never Aired! / Iconic M*A*S*H Restaurant Coming To Kroger? / Matt Damon, Bill Murray, and Graham Norton - Big Laughs! / When Lucy Got Fired / Partridge Family and Brady Bunch at Kings Island theme park 1972-73 / Awkward Talk Show Moments / Allan Blye Interview / Jack Benny's Last Tonight Show 1974 / Patricia Heaton's Audition for Everybody Loves Raymond / Luke Perry's Last Role / Johnny Cash's Last Interview / Judy Garland's Last Film / Who Was Bob Gordon? / Richard Dreyfuss vs Bill Murray / Jeff Ross vs Everybody / Tennessee Williams 1972 Interview / Ed Asner Interview / Norm Macdonald vs OJ Simpson / Tony Kornheiser Interview / Freddy's Nightmares TV Series / Awful 1990s TV Shows / The Funniest Comebacks in Talk Show History / Was Sonny Bono Murdered? / Robin Williams' Mrs. Doubtfire Screen Tests / Robert Downey Jr Asks for Forgiveness for Mel Gibson / Russell Brand / Hank Williams: The Show He Never Gave / Judy Garland vs Liz Taylor / Emmy Award Multiple Winners / Nathaniel Taylor aka Rollo Lawson / Anthony Zuiker: Mr. CSI / Jimmy & Cher / Diana Muldaur: A Viewer's History / Uncle Andy's Funhouse / Bea Arthur vs Betty White / Skidoo: Worst All-Star Comedy Ever? / Every Marvel Cartoon Opening Theme From 1966 - Present / When Stars Play Themselves / My Pen Pal is in the Pen, Pal / Small Roles Big Performances / Barbara Hall / Stars Before They Were Famous / Stars Before They Were Famous 2 / Stars Before They Were Famous 3 / A Better Classic TV Network / Bill Paxton / Who Was the Black Daliah? / How Frasier Was Created / Music Videos / Chitty Chitty Bang Bang - Behind the Scenes / Shirley Jones Interview / What We Lost When We Lost VHS / When Hit TV Shows Return / Commercials Starring Sopranos Cast Members / Shows Nobody Remembers But Me 4 / Shows Nobody Remembers But Me 1 / Bryan Cranston Interview / FREE streaming movie service you didn’t know you have / The Great Cable TV Migration / Sportscaster Woody Durham / Movie Posters and the documentary 24x36 /Chris Robinson /Dallas Reboot /David Letterman /Auditioning For Game Shows in the 80s /Ghosts of Cable TV past / Honey Boo Boo - WTF?!? / Steven Bochco Tribute / Ian Abercrombie / Joe Franklin / John Nettles / Gotham / Jon Cryer / Jon Stewart / Lana Wood / David Letterman / Matt Bomer / Molly Ringwald / Morgan Brittany / Music Rights for TV Shows / Neilsen Ratings / Norman Lloyd / Not Your Dad's TV / TV Series Reunions / Rich Little / Special Bulletin with George Clooney / Howard Stern VS Jamie Foxx / Top Ten Action Movies / 2013 Emmy Awards / 2010 Celebrity Deaths
Lost Kid Shows / Movie Stars on TV / Saturday Morning Shows / Video Vault / TV Goodbyes / Fabulous Fifties / Unseen Scenes / Game Shows / Requested Forgotten TV Shows / The Super Sixties / More Modern TV Shows / The New * * Shows / 1980's Wrestling / TV Blog
|TV's Embarrassing Moments / Action Shows of the Sixties / TVparty Mysteries and Scandals / Variety Shows of the 1970s / The Eighties / The Laugh Track / 1970's Hit Shows / Response to TVparty / Search the Site / Add Your Comments